Pages

Total Pageviews

Sunday, April 1, 2012

It's Not JUST Semantics: Trafficking DOES NOT Equal Sex Work

I originally posted on this issue in January, but in light of recent events, I have edited and added to this old post. 

April 1, 2012


Check out this article from The Good Men Project by Raymond Bechard:

What Do You Really Know About Hookers?


I feel like screaming it from the top of my crappy apartment....TRAFFICKING IS SLAVERY, IT IS NOT THE SAME AS CONSENSUAL SEX WORK!!!! I would probably consider going outside to scream this, except it's way too cold. And there's snow. Anyways, what is the deal with this guy? Can someone please explain it to me, because I'm at a loss. He writes:

"What can be stated as fact in the realm of commercial sexual exploitation, human trafficking, and prostitution is limited to the human suffering of its individual victims. Each of them began their lives with promise. And each of them had that promise broken and torn away. Though our urge to quantify the problem often compromises our rational and critical judgment, we must not also let it diminish the humanity of the individual who is fighting to escape and survive."

Hmm..is he sure about that? Has he actually spoken to a real prostitute, who is choosing to be a sex worker, and who feels proud and empowered by her choices (and by all of the cash that she's raking in)? I bet he hasn't. I know plenty of sex workers who aren't suffering. Or...am I just hallucinating?

I left this comment in response to his article:

"What do I know about hookers? Quite a lot actually. I know enough to know that prostitution/sex work IS NOT THE SAME THING as human trafficking. I don’t understand why the author continues to confuse the two. I think his campaign against the trafficking of individuals who are underage and/or forced into sex slavery is a very important one. However, why can’t we just keep the facts straight? The author constantly uses the words “hooker” and “prostitution,” referring to the work of consenting adult sex workers. If the author cannot distinguish between these two very different things, then what makes him a credible source? I find this to be very worrisome…

I am a sex worker advocate, and know many women who have been involved in the sex industry (whether it be escorting, pornography, or dancing) by choice, and who were proud of their career choice. These are not women who are being forced or coerced. These are women who have made a choice to do what they wish with THEIR bodies. Shouldn’t we all have that basic right?

If prostitution were legal in CT (and other states), we would likely see a drop in trafficking. Prostitution would have actual regulations, and workers could have access to medical screens, as well as legal rights. Connecticut would save approximately half a million dollars per year if police stopped wasting their time arresting prostitutes. Anyways…I digress. My point is that PROSTITUTION IS NOT THE SAME AS TRAFFICKING. The title of this article is misleading, as there is no actual mention of real “hookers” in the article.
For an actual dose of truth regarding sex work, check out my blog at http://legalizetoprotect.blogspot.com
I am a sex worker advocate in CT, and starting a Sex Workers Outreach Project in my state.
Xoxo
Page"

Look, I'm all for freedom of speech, and this man certainly has the right to publish these articles. Also, I don't doubt that he's doing a lot of great work for the community. But seriously, can he just get his facts and semantics straight?

It does a disservice to BOTH populations, workers and victims, to compare the two. Sex workers have a choice, whereas victims of trafficking do not. It's quite insulting that anyone would compare the two. Essentially, it's comparing a victim of rape to a woman who's having consensual sex. Take a moment to think of the ramifications of that statement. Rape myths, anyone?


Bechard is also very instrumental in the anti-backpage ad crusade. I have written about this issue in a different post, but as I edit, I think it makes more sense to have all of this information in one place. This is a post that I wrote on January 3, 2012:



Below is a link to an article written by Raymond Bechard, June 24, 2011:

The Controversy Around Backpage Ads


Has The Hartford Advocate Stopped Human Trafficking Advertising? "Not Yet."

Ok, I get it. Dennis Paris was guilty of trafficking minors on the Berlin Turnpike, claiming that he had an "escort business." Dennis would advertise in The Hartford Advocate's Back Room section (yes, we have all seen it...who doesn't check out The Advocate's fun section from time to time? C'mon now). Thankfully, Dennis is serving 30 years in federal prison. Ok wait...the story doesn't end yet. 

The point of the article is to get readers all riled up at the fact that The Advocate continues to print their Back Room section (I'm reading it right now...oooh..All Natural 40DDD Voluptuous, Mature Blond. In-calls only!). *GASP* How could The Advocate continue to do such a thing!? Ok, so are you riled up and angry yet, ready to call The Advocate???

I hope not. If you are, you've missed the point. Yes, it's true that Dennis Paris used The Back Room in order to traffick minors, and this is disgusting. However, the majority of the advertisements in the Back Room are placed by consenting adult sex workers. 

If we are to shut down The Back Room, we may as well shut down the millions of porn sites on the internet, all because of the child porn sites that exist. I have also read articles on this same topic that discuss the dangers of prostitution, the exploitation of women. Wait a second....I thought that the sex trafficking of minors was the concern....hmmmm. So, are these folks that are against the trafficking of minors also against prostitution? Are they aware that these are different issues, and that most of the women who put ads in The Advocate are regular ol' adult sex workers? Does anybody care about their rights?

So, that brings us to my next point. If The Back Room (and other backpage ads) are shut down, how will this affect sex workers?

This article brings up some great points:
Making Sex Workers Visible In The Online Ad Controversy

“Efforts to close down third-party advertisers are a shortsighted and misguided tactic to address trafficking,” said the New York City branch of the grassroots Sex Workers Outreach Project (SWOP), in correspondence with In These Times. Blanket crackdowns endanger sex workers by forcing them “further underground,” potentially pushing vulnerable people away from social services and other initiatives that could alleviate the social and economic oppression often underpinning sexual coercion."

SWOP-NYC argues:
"Sex work is real work, which means sex workers have the basic labor rights we all expect, including a work environment free of violence and exploitation. Targeting companies that work with people in commercial sex will only lead to more shrouded interactions. This marginalization and isolation increases violence, HIV/STI transmission and stigmatization, hinders access to basic services, and promotes a loss of autonomy over the conditions in which people engage in the industry. There is so much we can do to prevent trafficking and support people who do want to move out of the sex industry, and these tactics only pull valuable resources from those strategies.
The voice commonly missing from the media coverage on the Village Voice and Craigslist is that of sex workers. It has become too easy to forget that there are real people involved with sex work with real human and labor rights."

It's always important to look at both sides of every story. Just sayin'. Now back to browsing The Back Room....



Alright, so there's a twist here. Bechard lives in my city, and regularly comes to the University that I attend. Should I take that as an opportunity to speak to him? It's unlikely that an abolitionist will want to hear anything about sex worker's rights, but perhaps it's worth a shot? Decisions, decisions...


Page




Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Seriously, WTF!?!?!?

I posted this on my facebook wall today. Brace yourselves because I'm about to get bitchy:
"Melissa Cann made this video about her sister, Maureen, who was tragically murdered by the Long Island Serial Killer.  Love 
The killer still hasn't been caught. Maureen was a sex worker, and also much more. Our jobs do not define us. It's heartbreaking that when sex workers are brutally murdered, we rarely hear about it. The women killed were daughters, friends, mothers, and partners of people just like you and I. They deserve respect, just like any other murder victim. 
There is a donation page, http://www.everribbon.com/stunts4justice, where the family's are collecting donations to go towards the reward for anyone who has valuable information on the killer's identity. I donated, and so did my mother (and she's unemployed!) Why haven't you? Seriously, I can't believe that out of the 591 facebook friends I have, no one has contributed. Sorry to shame you all, but sometimes we need to be ashamed."
Yeah, I know that was a bitchy post, but I'm sort of known for being a bitch. Seriously though, I see so many other fundraisers that bring in the big bucks- why? Because they're for victims that society "favors." I GUARANTEE if these murder victims were young children, nuns, or celebrities, the donations would be POURING in! But, they were prostitutes. So, it's likely that you've never even heard about this case, and that's really sad. Please take a minute to think about what it would be like to be the sister, mother, or daughter of one of these young women. 
So, what I'm trying to say it, get off your lazy butts and donate, even $10. $5. Anything. Most of us have that to donate, and if you don't, then do your part to pass the link along to others that can donate. Raise awareness! I hate to say this, but I am disappointed that I have almost 600 facebook friends, and none of them donated. I tweeted this to many other sex worker advocates, and none of them donated or retweeted. The only person that did retweet was Tera Patrick, a famous porn stay with 30,000 follows. That's a woman with a good heart.
Watch that 3 minute video clip titled "Love," and you will realize why it's so sad that no one seems to be listening. I think about the people that I love most in my life, and if they were murdered, I would be shattered. Their occupations wouldn't have a single fucking thing to do with anything.
For the record- I never met any of the victims. I've never even met the sister, Melissa Cann, although I have corresponded with her on several occasions. Even though I don't have any personal ties to the women who were murdered, I am a woman, and a sex worker advocate and I believe this tragedy needs to receive more attention than it has. 
Please donate, or at least pass this on. If you had time to read this post, then you have time to donate a few bucks. 
RIP 
xoxo
Page

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Victims of Violence Are Not "Sacks of Bones"

Hello friends & advocates,

This is something that is VERY important to me, so please take a few minutes out of your day to read this.

An unidentified serial killer (referred to as The Long Island Serial Killer) murdered 10 people over the past several years, leaving their bodies along the Ocean Parkway. Among the victims that were identified were Amber Lynn Costello, Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelemy, Maureen Brainard-Barnes.

These women were sex workers, and they were also much more than that. They do not deserve to be referred to as "sacks of bones."  I am disgusted that NOW-NYC would refer to victims of violence in such a way. PLEASE read the following open letter to NOW-NYC, written by members of Sex Workers Outreach Project NYC (SWOP-NYC) and Sex Workers Action New York (SWANK).

 Open Letter to NOW-NYC

Ok, step 1 is reading the letter. Step 2 is showing your support by signing it. Please email swank@riseup.net if you would like to add your name. I have done it, and you should too. Victims shouldn't be called "sacks of bones," and NOW-NYC should have more respect for victims of violence.

Also, please check out the following link to contribute to the reward funds for the capture of the Long Island Serial Killer.   Stunts 4 Justice- Donate

Instead of going out tonight and buying that expensive drink, donate that $10 to this important cause. I'm about to make my donation right now.

I'm really sick of living in a society where there's SO much violence against women. Please share this post if you are sick of it too.



Saturday, March 24, 2012

Am I A SLUT? Slut slut slut!!!

What is a slut? I spend a lot of time talking about "slut shaming," and advocating for a woman's right to explore her sexuality. I proudly marched in SlutwalkNYC, and wore a shirt that said "SLUT" across the chest in large letters. But...what is a slut? I think everyone has their own version of what that word means, and it's safe to say that we aren't all on the same page. I'd like to take a little time to explore the word "slut." Shall we?

Ok, so let's start with one of my FAVORITE resources, Urban Dictionary! They provide a few definitions of the word slut:


1. Slut: A woman with the morals of a man.

2. Slut: Someone who provides a very needed service for the community and sleeps with everyone, even the guy that has no shot at getting laid and everyone knows it. She will give him a sympathy fuck either because someone asked her to or she just has to fuck everyone she knows. These are great people, and without them sex crimes would definitly increase. Thank you slut, where ever you are.

3. Slut:  A derogatory term. Refers to a sexually promiscuous person, usually female. One who engages in sexual activity with a large number of persons, occasionally simultaneously. Also refers to one who engages in sexual activity outside of a long-term relationship within the duration of said relationship. These sexual activities include but are not limited to: passionate kissing, manual stimulation of genitalia and/or breasts in the case of a female; oral stimulation of these parts; sexual intercourse. In some cases, used to refer to a woman who is wearing "skimpy" or tasteless clothing. Less commonly, used as a derogatory term by one female for another during periods of conflict.
 
Ok, so definition #1 is pretty vague- a woman with the morals of a man. Well, that still doesn't answer the original question- what is a slut? What qualities would a man need to possess in order to be labeled as a slut? Since slut is usually used in a derogatory manner, does this mean that men have bad morals, or is it only problematic when women act this way? 

Definition #2, holy shit. What a disaster. 

But seriously...okay definition # 2 applauds women for their slutty behavior. By this definition, women are like saints who provide community service by having sex with ugly men. This is pretty disturbing, isn't it? Also, there's the assertion that if more women were sluts, sexual assault would decrease. As in- "well, if more women would put out, then we wouldn't have to rape them." 

So, according to definition #2, sluts are good for society because they satisfy the needs of men/animals who can't control themselves. So, not only does definition #2 insult men, but it also reminds women that if they get raped, it's their fault. Interesting definition...Oh, and the dumbass that wrote the definition can't spell. Just saying.

Ok- so what the hell is a slut?? It's a woman that acts like a man, but also assists men by servicing their rabid sexual appetites. So, a man who services other men- a gay man? Now I'm getting all confused. Maybe definition #3 can shed some more light on this predicament...

Definition #3 is probably the best one of the three. So basically, a slut is a woman who has lots of sex with a large number of individuals and possibly cheats on her partner. Who decides what qualifies as a "large number?" 3? 33? 333? Who decides? 

Also, this definition states that a slut has lots of sex, and sometimes does the same while in a relationship. Ok, so whether or not she has a partner, she's a slut if she's having lots of sex. Hmm...what does society call women who are single and DON'T have sex? Prudes. Frigid. Bitch.

So, should we be sluts, or prudes? If the golden number for "too many partners" is 4, and we have sex with 5 people, are we sluts, or just a little trampy? What if we only have sex with people that we are in relationships with, but have MANY relationships- is that slutty? 

The definition also points out that a woman can be considered a slut based on the clothing that she's wearing. So, if a virgin is wearing a short skirt and/or a low top, is she also a slut? 

Damned if you do, damned if you don't. Slut if you do, prude if you don't! 

So- am I a slut? I like to have sex, and I've had sex with more than 1 person in my lifetime. I have had sex with boyfriends, and I have had sex with men that were not boyfriends. I wore a short dress while I was in Florida this past week. Ok, I guess I'm a slut. According to definition #2, I'm saving the rest of the world from being sexually assaulted. Wow, I deserve an award! 

Seriously though...fuck all of these definitions, every single one. Next time somebody calls you a slut, ask them what that word means to them. I'm curious.
 
Xoxo
 
Page

ps- No, that is not me in the picture, but it's a cool picture, right? According to definition #3, she's a slut! Also, did you enjoy reading this article? If so, then you should buy me a coffee by contributing to my blog fund. Yeah, I know what you're thinking, but seriously, a girl's gotta do what she's gotta do! Oops, does that make me a slut?