Hey friends! I recently did an interview for up and coming magazine, Raw Attraction. Here is the link, and I've also posted it here for your reading pleasure :) Please feel free to comment & share if you enjoy!
Raw Attraction Magazine
We speak to Christina Parreira, M.A who is a PhD Sociology student with a
primary focus on sex work & prostitution. She is also a 'web cam'
girl. We wanted to speak to her about how this affects her life and
public perception of her.
At Raw, we believe women (and men) should be able to do what they want with their bodies as long as they are happy.
Christina... Tell me a little about yourself and why you decided to step into webcam work
I
had been in a relationship for a few years, and my partner and I were
looking for ways to spice things up. One of our friends told us about
couples who broadcast live on amateur porn sites, and I was intrigued.
It proved to be a fun way to add new excitement to our sex life, but it
wasn't something we were charging money for. Honestly, I didn't even
consider the possibility of profiting from it when we started. At the
time, I was working on my Masters in clinical psychology and the
majority of my income came from student loans. I was also working as a
waitress part-time, but I was really burnt out on restaurant jobs.
As
soon as I realized that other performers on the site were profiting
from cam work, I refused to do it for free. Why on earth would I do
something for free that others were getting paid for? Unfortunately, my
partner wasn't thrilled with my new plan. He felt that it became all
about work, and that getting paid took the fun out of what was initially
something meant to improve our sex life. We eventually parted ways (not
because of the cam work) and I continued to work as a cam model on my
own. I started my doctorate and continued to work as a cam performer,
and fortunately was able to take out fewer student loans thanks to my
new source of income.
What do you normally do when you are on web cam? How do you feel when you are working?
Earnings
vary depending on how many hours I work, how many clients are online,
the time of day. Much like waitressing and stripping, it can be very hit
or miss. It took me a while to build up my fan base, my "regulars" as I
call them. It also depends on the website's traffic and how well the
site promotes itself. Once I established myself as a cam performer, I'd
average anywhere from $100-300 per night. Sometimes more, sometimes
less. I took a 6 month break between academic programs and during that
period, cam work became a full time job. I was consistently earning over
a grand a week. I was working 5-6 nights per week on cam.
As
far as what I normally do on cam, it really varies based on what the
client requests. Some clients want what I refer to as a "standard show:"
a strip tease and a toy show. However I also cater to a lot of fetish
clients, and that doesn't even involve nudity. I've done hundreds of
foot fetish shows, dominatrix shows, role play, cuckold and humiliation,
etc. When I am on cam, I feel that I am fulfilling a role, a fantasy.
Honestly, it doesn't feel a whole lot different than when I used to work
at a bar. I'm paid to perform a service and if I'm comfortable with
that service and I agree to the terms, I accept payment and I do the
best I can to please the client. I will admit that at first, camming was
a novelty. I felt sexy, I felt a thrill from it. As the years went on,
it turned into a boring job just like any other. I go through the
motions, get paid, and sign off. I've actually been spending less and
less time on cam. I'm starting to feel burnt out from it, and I have
much less patience for irritating clients. I've been doing this work for
almost five years, and with anything else, it gets tiresome.
Are you able to easily tell new boyfriends/lovers about your work? If yes, how do they react?
When
I first started cam work, I was much less confident about telling
others. It was a source of anxiety for me, and I was concerned over what
future partners would think. I think that was part of being young and
insecure. At this point in my life, I feel confident in who I am and in
what I do. I'm also passionate about advocating for the civil and human
rights of sex workers and have met many incredible sex workers/activists
over the last couple of years. Being around other individuals who do
similar work has helped to empower me. I won't date anyone who is not
okay with what I do, and I am always upfront. Given that sex work is
such a large part of my life, both in how I make my money and in my
academic interests, it would be near impossible for me to hide. I don't
think I should have to hide it, and I certainly won't have anyone
telling me what I can and cannot do with my body. If somebody cannot
accept that I'm a sex worker, they can head towards the door.
When
I was younger, I had partners who were insecure about the whole cam
thing. Those relationships didn't last long. My last serious partner was
involved in the adult film industry, and so he was supportive of my
work. It was one of the few things in our relationship that wasn't
problematic! Currently, I'm single and taking a break from dating. I've
had a string of unhealthy relationships and am at a point in which I
need to take time to work on myself and to focus on my academic work. I
can't be bothered to worry how future partners will react.
How has it changed you in terms of your attitudes to sex and in the bedroom when you are having sex?
This
is an interesting question, and one that I'm still exploring. I don't
know if I have a clear answer to this yet. It's not black and white. Our
attitudes and behaviors change as we progress, and as a result of
exposure to many influences. How can I know exactly what has been a
direct result of being a sex worker and what has been a result of
exposure to past relationships, sexual partners, etc? There's overlap
there. It's not cut and dry.
I've always been pretty open when
it comes to sex, but I can definitely say that cam work has broadened my
awareness. I am more accepting of different fetishes and fantasies.
For example, when I was new to cam work, I did not understand how or why
somebody could be turned on by feet. I was shocked by some of the
requests that I got from clients! To be honest, I thought some of it was
really weird! I'm more open minded now, and I have more appreciation
for the broad spectrum of human sexuality. Actually, I feel really
privileged in a way. I've been allowed into the deepest darkest corners
of people's minds. Men have shared their secret desires with me, and
it's been fascinating.
Has sex work changed my behavior in the
bedroom? Maybe we should call up some of my exs? Just kidding. Well,
anything that a person does for five years will have an impact, but I'm
still trying to figure out what that impact is. Occasionally when I'm
having sex with a partner, I notice that I may "amp it up" a bit, as I
would when I'm in front of the camera. It's one thing for me to keep an
eye on. I've noticed this more when I'm with casual partners rather than
when I'm in a relationship. I'm very comfortable with my sexuality, and
perhaps that's a result of being a sex worker. However, as I've already
said, I'm not comfortable with making a statement such as "I'm
comfortable in bed because I'm a sex worker." That's assuming direct
causation without taking other variables into account. I'm much more
than just my job, and I've been exposed to many other things that may
have affected who I am sexually. Sex work is only one facet.
What are some of the craziest fantasies that guys come up with?
I
hate to say that any fantasy is "crazy," as that has a judgmental tone
to it. However, there were some that surprised me, mostly due to a lack
of exposure. I've seen clients use clothes pins on themselves, rope,
nipple clamps, etc. I don't think that this is by any means "crazy," but
I suppose by many people's standards it may be thought of as unusual.
We should be careful to not shame anyone for their preferences though.
Actually, I will say this- the bestiality people freak me out. I can be
judgmental about that because it is abusive and unethical. I have a dog
and I've had clients request "dog shows," and I tell those people to go
to hell.
What is your opinion on the male species after working in the industry?
My
answer to the "male species" question is the same as my answer to the
sexuality question. It's hard to say how much sex work has played a
role, and how much my previous experiences & relationships have
played a role. Also important to note that I have had a few female
clients. They're rare, but they exist! I know plenty of females who
enjoy porn, but it seems that fewer are willing to pay for it. So, I
don't want to make any sweeping generalizations about a gender based on
my work. Perhaps more women would be willing to pay for cam girl
services if it were more socially acceptable for women to express their
urges and desires. Women often get shamed for their sexual urges, so
they're not given equal opportunity to explore them. But, back to the
question of men, I have been guilty of statements such as "Ugh men are
such pigs!" and so forth. I really don't want to turn into that though.
Also, I have to admit that I'm probably not in the best position to
articulate my views on men at the moment. In my personal life I've had
negative experiences with men over the past year, and as I mentioned
earlier, I'm taking a long break from dating. So, how much of this is a
result of my cam work and how much is a result of my previous
relationships? Ask me again in a couple of years!
What is your ultimate fantasy?
My
ultimate fantasy? Having sex with porn star James Deen in a Hello
Kitty-themed Love Hotel in Tokyo. Yes, that exists. Seriously, can you
think of anything better? I can't!
What are the positives from the work and what would you recommend to anyone wanting to get into it?
The
biggest positive from my work is without a doubt the money. That's why
we all work, isn't it? I also have a lot of freedom in terms of when I
work and how much I work. I am my own boss, and I love that. I'm able to
go to school and support myself. I've also met some interesting people
that also work in this industry. As far as advice for other women (and
men because men can be cam performers too!) I would say don't ever do
anything that you're not comfortable with. This work is not for
everyone. I cannot stress that enough: sex work is not for everyone and
that's okay. Observe your limits and boundaries. Check in with yourself.
If something feels right, then explore it. Perhaps even more
importantly, if something feels wrong, don't keep doing it! Be kind to
yourself and to your body.
You can find Christina at http://legalizetoprotect.blogspot.com/ and on twitter.com/SinCityGrrrl
A blog about sex worker rights, the sex industry, rape culture, slut-shaming, & everything in between (your legs and mine!)
Saturday, August 10, 2013
Tuesday, August 6, 2013
Slut Riot: A Sex Worker Shares Her Perspective
Hello friends! I am so pleased to announced that The Sin City Siren is doing a week long campaign about slut-shaming, including articles on the topic from different perspectives. Today's article comes from a sex worker- me! I have shared the link here as well as the article. Thank you so much to The Sin City Siren for this opportunity. Enjoy! XO
The Sin City Siren's Slut Riot!
By Christina Parreira, M.A.
Women who transgress traditional gender roles are often targets of ridicule, shaming, and even violence. What does it mean to violate these mores, and what type of women are most at risk? Women who exhibit promiscuous behavior are shamed for being sluts, but what about those who charge for it? Sex workers are arguably one of the most targeted groups when it comes to the phenomenon of slut-shaming.
American culture has a love/hate relationship with promiscuous women. I am reminded of the Madonna/Whore complex, a psychoanalytic theory which states that men view women as either virtuous saints or tarnished whores. According to the theory, it would be nearly impossible for a man to simultaneously respect a woman and explore his sexual fantasies with her. Granted, this theory is outdated, but I think it has some merit in the discussion of slut-shaming and sex work.
A sex worker is any individual who trades a sexual service for compensation. This includes porn performers, strippers, phone sex operators, escorts, prostitutes, webcam models, and so forth. Some sex workers work legally, while others work illegally. Unfortunately, the criminalization of prostitution in most of the US contributes to the shaming of sex workers, but even those who work legally experience slut-shaming. Porn and stripping are both legal jobs, but both come with high levels of stigma. Porn stars are the stuff that dirty wet dreams are made of, but you wouldn’t dare bring one home to mother … would you? Men shower strippers with dollar bills at bachelor parties, but many wouldn’t be caught dead dating one. The sex industry is a multi-billion dollar industry, and yet the performers who make up this industry are regarded as pariahs. The hypocrisy is stunning — to masturbate to these individuals in private but to damn them in the public sphere.
I have worked as a webcam performer for almost five years, and recently started stripping. I identify as a sex worker and receive the majority of my income from this work. I am also a graduate student. The reactions that I get from people when they learn that I’m a sex worker are astonishing. Even more confusion results when people learn that I am also a graduate student. Why is this? Are people stunned that sex workers also have brains? Why aren’t we allowed to be simultaneously intellectual AND sexual? How does the exchange of money affect people’s perceptions of individuals and the level of slut-shaming that takes place? Women who exhibit “slutty” behavior are already damned, but what about those who profit financially from this behavior? The shaming is even more amplified. Not only are we sluts, but we have the nerve to charge for it! It is important to note that this does not only apply to female sex workers, but also to male and transgendered workers.
Society targets sex workers the way it used to target the so-called witches of Salem. Individuals who engage in sex work shatter the widely held beliefs of what constitutes socially appropriate behavior, making sex workers a prime target for slut-shaming. I hope to one day live in a world where I can do as I please with my genitals without being shamed. A world in which a rape victim isn’t blamed for what she was wearing. Unfortunately, I think we have a long way to go.
The Sin City Siren's Slut Riot!
Slut Riot: A sex worker shares her perspective
In today’s installment of Slut Riot we hear from a sex worker who also happens to be a graduate student. I encourage you to read her words and consider any assumptions that float into your head. Do you pre-judge her before you even start because you hold sex workers to a different standard? Can sex workers be slut-shamed when their vocation requires the real or imagined acts of promiscuity? Keep in mind that the social caste system that marginalizes and even dehumanizes sex workers is just an extension of the pervasive patriarchy all around us.By Christina Parreira, M.A.
Women who transgress traditional gender roles are often targets of ridicule, shaming, and even violence. What does it mean to violate these mores, and what type of women are most at risk? Women who exhibit promiscuous behavior are shamed for being sluts, but what about those who charge for it? Sex workers are arguably one of the most targeted groups when it comes to the phenomenon of slut-shaming.
American culture has a love/hate relationship with promiscuous women. I am reminded of the Madonna/Whore complex, a psychoanalytic theory which states that men view women as either virtuous saints or tarnished whores. According to the theory, it would be nearly impossible for a man to simultaneously respect a woman and explore his sexual fantasies with her. Granted, this theory is outdated, but I think it has some merit in the discussion of slut-shaming and sex work.
A sex worker is any individual who trades a sexual service for compensation. This includes porn performers, strippers, phone sex operators, escorts, prostitutes, webcam models, and so forth. Some sex workers work legally, while others work illegally. Unfortunately, the criminalization of prostitution in most of the US contributes to the shaming of sex workers, but even those who work legally experience slut-shaming. Porn and stripping are both legal jobs, but both come with high levels of stigma. Porn stars are the stuff that dirty wet dreams are made of, but you wouldn’t dare bring one home to mother … would you? Men shower strippers with dollar bills at bachelor parties, but many wouldn’t be caught dead dating one. The sex industry is a multi-billion dollar industry, and yet the performers who make up this industry are regarded as pariahs. The hypocrisy is stunning — to masturbate to these individuals in private but to damn them in the public sphere.
I have worked as a webcam performer for almost five years, and recently started stripping. I identify as a sex worker and receive the majority of my income from this work. I am also a graduate student. The reactions that I get from people when they learn that I’m a sex worker are astonishing. Even more confusion results when people learn that I am also a graduate student. Why is this? Are people stunned that sex workers also have brains? Why aren’t we allowed to be simultaneously intellectual AND sexual? How does the exchange of money affect people’s perceptions of individuals and the level of slut-shaming that takes place? Women who exhibit “slutty” behavior are already damned, but what about those who profit financially from this behavior? The shaming is even more amplified. Not only are we sluts, but we have the nerve to charge for it! It is important to note that this does not only apply to female sex workers, but also to male and transgendered workers.
Society targets sex workers the way it used to target the so-called witches of Salem. Individuals who engage in sex work shatter the widely held beliefs of what constitutes socially appropriate behavior, making sex workers a prime target for slut-shaming. I hope to one day live in a world where I can do as I please with my genitals without being shamed. A world in which a rape victim isn’t blamed for what she was wearing. Unfortunately, I think we have a long way to go.
Thursday, August 1, 2013
Check Your References Ladies! Re: Hugo Schwyzer
Hello friends!
Hugo Schwyzer quit the internet, had an affair, and sexted with a 27-year old sex worker. Ahem.
I don't have the patience or energy to give much of the back story regarding this issue, so if you have no idea who Hugo Schwyzer is/what's going on with him, don't bother to read on.
For those of you who are keeping up with the controversy & reveling in every second of it, please continue.
First, I want to express my disgust with every single person who is participating in the shaming of a man with mental illness. It's perfectly acceptable to dislike somebody, to disagree with them, to point out the sheer hypocrisy of the situation. Feminists are pissed off and have reason to be, I get that. I won't spend time on that particular facet of the issue. There are dozens of other blogs and angry articles swirling around the twitter universe & blogosphere. Have your moment in the sun, Hugo-haters. You've been waiting for this day.
You know what's not cool? Poking fun at him for being in a psychiatric ward. Placing bets on when he will try to commit suicide. Rejoicing in his mental anguish. This is all shit that I've seen on twitter and it's disgusting. Despite his mistakes (and yes, they are mistakes. We've all made them- right?), he's still a HUMAN. It's interesting to see all of these human rights activists cheering for joy as they watch a human being's health decline. Very interesting, folks. Everyone loves a bully.
A real gem- "Hugo Schwyzer's meltdown is spectacular, and befitting a man of his craven stature. Be warned manboobs and ilk: your doom is preordained" twitter by @heartise
I've also seen the line "grown men are fragile" going around twitter, mocking Hugo's "quitting of the internet." So now we're shaming men for expression emotions? Real nice. Another fantastic display of feminism.
Tweets such as "hahahahaha a beautiful goodbye to the sensitive fucklord that is hugo schwyzer" by @voraciousbrain
What a fabulous society we live in. What's going to happen if Schwyzer actually commits suicide? Will everyone throw a party and piss on his grave? These people should be absolutely disgusted with their behavior. I have also suffered with mental illness and so perhaps I have a bit more empathy than others. Perhaps I also know a thing or two about being bullied and abused by those who hide behind a keyboard.
Sigh. What drama.
February was not a good month. Thankfully, I'm happily living in Las Vegas now and looking forward to starting my PhD in Sociology in less than 1 month! Woohooooooo! My future is bright and I'm feeling at peace (a rarity for me). I wish Hugo luck in his recovery. No one deserves to be shamed for having a mental illness.
From the bottom of my ever-changing, always learning, work in progress heart,
Christina Parreira
Hugo Schwyzer quit the internet, had an affair, and sexted with a 27-year old sex worker. Ahem.
I don't have the patience or energy to give much of the back story regarding this issue, so if you have no idea who Hugo Schwyzer is/what's going on with him, don't bother to read on.
For those of you who are keeping up with the controversy & reveling in every second of it, please continue.
First, I want to express my disgust with every single person who is participating in the shaming of a man with mental illness. It's perfectly acceptable to dislike somebody, to disagree with them, to point out the sheer hypocrisy of the situation. Feminists are pissed off and have reason to be, I get that. I won't spend time on that particular facet of the issue. There are dozens of other blogs and angry articles swirling around the twitter universe & blogosphere. Have your moment in the sun, Hugo-haters. You've been waiting for this day.
You know what's not cool? Poking fun at him for being in a psychiatric ward. Placing bets on when he will try to commit suicide. Rejoicing in his mental anguish. This is all shit that I've seen on twitter and it's disgusting. Despite his mistakes (and yes, they are mistakes. We've all made them- right?), he's still a HUMAN. It's interesting to see all of these human rights activists cheering for joy as they watch a human being's health decline. Very interesting, folks. Everyone loves a bully.
A real gem- "Hugo Schwyzer's meltdown is spectacular, and befitting a man of his craven stature. Be warned manboobs and ilk: your doom is preordained" twitter by @heartise
I've also seen the line "grown men are fragile" going around twitter, mocking Hugo's "quitting of the internet." So now we're shaming men for expression emotions? Real nice. Another fantastic display of feminism.
Tweets such as "hahahahaha a beautiful goodbye to the sensitive fucklord that is hugo schwyzer" by @voraciousbrain
What a fabulous society we live in. What's going to happen if Schwyzer actually commits suicide? Will everyone throw a party and piss on his grave? These people should be absolutely disgusted with their behavior. I have also suffered with mental illness and so perhaps I have a bit more empathy than others. Perhaps I also know a thing or two about being bullied and abused by those who hide behind a keyboard.
Sigh. What drama.
February was not a good month. Thankfully, I'm happily living in Las Vegas now and looking forward to starting my PhD in Sociology in less than 1 month! Woohooooooo! My future is bright and I'm feeling at peace (a rarity for me). I wish Hugo luck in his recovery. No one deserves to be shamed for having a mental illness.
From the bottom of my ever-changing, always learning, work in progress heart,
Christina Parreira
Monday, March 11, 2013
My Experience At A Feminist Conference: On Censorship, Objectification, & What It Means For Me
I'm writing this as I sit and wait for my flight, watching planes take off over the mountains of Salt Lake City. This would be a serene moment, if it were not for the rumbling of my upset stomach after eating McDonalds for breakfast. As if I don't already know better. Anyways, I am heading home after spending a wonderful five days at the Association for Women in Psychology (AWP) conference, where I presented my project, "Sexism, Strippers, and Slut-Shaming," as part of a symposium. I was fortunate to spend time with former professors and colleagues that I haven't seen since leaving Connecticut. I was pleasantly surprised with Salt Lake City. My stereotypes were in full force when the plane touched down, and the woman who sat behind me rambling about the evils of welfare did not help. In reality, the city wasn't the scary Republican hellhole that I had imagined. We enjoyed good shopping (maybe too much shopping?), food (I tried Lebanese AND Himalayan food!), and of course several thought-provoking lectures as part of AWP.
The conversations that were had in these feminist spaces were stimulating, but not always comfortable. I found myself constantly vacillating between "Yes, I'm a feminist" and "No, my ideals don't fit with traditional feminist ideology, so therefore, I am not a feminist." The topic of violence in the media came up over dinner conversation, which led to a discussion of Rhianna and Chris Brown's newly rekindled romance. The knee-jerk reaction always being the same; "they're terrible, he's an abuser, she hasn't made any public statements that would help young women, they're setting a bad example, her lyrics are glorifying violence against women." At least one of these statements was my own, and I'm not disputing the validity of any of them. I'm not interested in having that sort of discussion or writing about it. That's not what this is about. This is about the proposed solutions. Just as many radical feminists (ahem, Gail Dines) would love to see porn censored, there are feminists who would like to see this couple, and their music, disappear. I will admit that I became defensive during the discussion, reminding everyone that shame and censorship DO NOT WORK.
Other points of interest- do her lyrics really glorify what happened to her? Who are we to judge her words, her art? Who the fuck cares what she's glorifying/not glorifying; in a community that values free speech, shouldn't this woman be allowed to express herself, and her pain, in whatever medium she chooses? Whose responsibility is it to make sure that young "impressionable" women don't hear these messages? What about starting in the home, and with education? The same could be said of porn. Porn is not meant to be used as sex education, and if it is, then we have a problem in homes and school systems. Why are we relying on media (that is supposed to be consumed by adults) to teach our kids about sex and relationships?
Back to Rhianna- it made me feel uncomfortable that she never released a public statement in regards to getting back together with Brown. I would have been more comfortable if she had said something along the lines of "What he did was terrible, but he is seeking treatment" or any variations of this. Let's look at how my statement began, shall we? "I would have been more comfortable." Well, art/music/writing isn't about making me, or anyone else, "more comfortable." If you don't like it, go out and create something that you do like. Don't censor, create something better. After all, does the removal of potentially harmful things ever actually work? Well, the war on drugs was a great success, so, perhaps.
Quick point on Brown- yes, he abused her. Does this mean he will always be an abuser? Fuck no. How could I have training and experience in the field of clinical psychology and have the nerve to assert that an abuser will never change? Is it likely? Is it easy? No, no. However, there's a danger when we begin to make blanket statements such as "once an abuser, always an abuser," when we assume that there is no room for improvement, no room for growth. These were statements and sentiments that I heard expressed various times throughout the conference, and it scared me.
Now, there's nothing wrong with discussions these issues. In fact, I think we should be talking about this topic; how it makes us feel, what we believe is the public perception, what young women and men are learning from these highly publicized romantic relationships. Unfortunately, in feminist spaces, I have noticed the conversation veer towards censorship far too many times. Just as it has done about porn, and about portrayals of violence in media. When we begin to censor, where do we draw the line? Honestly, the whole idea frightens me; it scares the shit out of me.
Now, switching gears. One of the highlights of the trip was a conversation that I had with a fantastic feminist professor whom with I had previously worked. We discussed our views on pornography, sex work, and the objectification of women. We also discussed the hierarchy that exists within sex work, and I was the first to say that as as young white women, I am part of the privileged end of the continuum. There is no doubt about it. I have good height/weight proportions, white skin, and am in my 20's. There is no fucking way I am facing the same adversity as a minority status sex worker in her 40's. Or, I could have just left off the age, let's leave it at "minority sex worker." It's an intersection of age, gender, sexual orientation, class, race, and to pretend that it's not is just ignorance, period. What does this really mean in terms of choice? What do I do with this knowledge and how can I still do good work within the community? Well, that's a conversation for another day, and one in which I look forward to having with others at the Desiree Alliance conference. My chat with this professor primed me for many NECESSARY conversations in the future. But, back to objectification. It's her belief that pornography, and the constant images of "sexy" women that serve as nothing more than jerk-off material, perpetuate a culture in which women's bodies are used and discarded. We agreed on the terms of objectification, but not on the implications. I am objectifying myself, there's no doubt about it. Do I feel good about this objectification, and am I making a choice to do it? Yes, and yes. It was a refreshing discussion, because unlike so many other feminists that I have talked to, her response was "and that's your choice, and it's okay. But, in regards to this issue, you're not a feminist." Would you believe that I actually felt liberated when she said this? I'm not a feminist, and that's okay. No judgment, no shaming, no chastising. I am making a choice, and that's okay. It also doesn't mean that I can't hold feminist ideals in other arenas, it doesn't need to be so black and white. Honestly, one of the most thought-provoking conversations that I have had in a long while.
Perhaps this objectification does have a negative impact on culture and the way in which women view themselves. Just as perhaps violent media and song lyrics have a negative impact, but again, what's the solution? We come full circle. It's not censorship; it's not pulling all porn off the internet; it's not telling sex workers to stop objectifying themselves; it's not telling Rhianna that she needs to stop expressing herself. Or that she needs to make a public apology, just to make US feel better about HER trauma.
I feel the need to end this article by saying that I wrote this much as I would write an entry in my journal. These are only my views, and they're expressed (perhaps not as eloquently as they could have been) after five days at a conference. I wanted to share some of my thoughts and insights, and that's it. Pick them apart and bitch at me all you want, but they're still only MY views, and I'm allowed to have them.. Thanks for reading.
The conversations that were had in these feminist spaces were stimulating, but not always comfortable. I found myself constantly vacillating between "Yes, I'm a feminist" and "No, my ideals don't fit with traditional feminist ideology, so therefore, I am not a feminist." The topic of violence in the media came up over dinner conversation, which led to a discussion of Rhianna and Chris Brown's newly rekindled romance. The knee-jerk reaction always being the same; "they're terrible, he's an abuser, she hasn't made any public statements that would help young women, they're setting a bad example, her lyrics are glorifying violence against women." At least one of these statements was my own, and I'm not disputing the validity of any of them. I'm not interested in having that sort of discussion or writing about it. That's not what this is about. This is about the proposed solutions. Just as many radical feminists (ahem, Gail Dines) would love to see porn censored, there are feminists who would like to see this couple, and their music, disappear. I will admit that I became defensive during the discussion, reminding everyone that shame and censorship DO NOT WORK.
Other points of interest- do her lyrics really glorify what happened to her? Who are we to judge her words, her art? Who the fuck cares what she's glorifying/not glorifying; in a community that values free speech, shouldn't this woman be allowed to express herself, and her pain, in whatever medium she chooses? Whose responsibility is it to make sure that young "impressionable" women don't hear these messages? What about starting in the home, and with education? The same could be said of porn. Porn is not meant to be used as sex education, and if it is, then we have a problem in homes and school systems. Why are we relying on media (that is supposed to be consumed by adults) to teach our kids about sex and relationships?
Back to Rhianna- it made me feel uncomfortable that she never released a public statement in regards to getting back together with Brown. I would have been more comfortable if she had said something along the lines of "What he did was terrible, but he is seeking treatment" or any variations of this. Let's look at how my statement began, shall we? "I would have been more comfortable." Well, art/music/writing isn't about making me, or anyone else, "more comfortable." If you don't like it, go out and create something that you do like. Don't censor, create something better. After all, does the removal of potentially harmful things ever actually work? Well, the war on drugs was a great success, so, perhaps.
Quick point on Brown- yes, he abused her. Does this mean he will always be an abuser? Fuck no. How could I have training and experience in the field of clinical psychology and have the nerve to assert that an abuser will never change? Is it likely? Is it easy? No, no. However, there's a danger when we begin to make blanket statements such as "once an abuser, always an abuser," when we assume that there is no room for improvement, no room for growth. These were statements and sentiments that I heard expressed various times throughout the conference, and it scared me.
Now, there's nothing wrong with discussions these issues. In fact, I think we should be talking about this topic; how it makes us feel, what we believe is the public perception, what young women and men are learning from these highly publicized romantic relationships. Unfortunately, in feminist spaces, I have noticed the conversation veer towards censorship far too many times. Just as it has done about porn, and about portrayals of violence in media. When we begin to censor, where do we draw the line? Honestly, the whole idea frightens me; it scares the shit out of me.
Now, switching gears. One of the highlights of the trip was a conversation that I had with a fantastic feminist professor whom with I had previously worked. We discussed our views on pornography, sex work, and the objectification of women. We also discussed the hierarchy that exists within sex work, and I was the first to say that as as young white women, I am part of the privileged end of the continuum. There is no doubt about it. I have good height/weight proportions, white skin, and am in my 20's. There is no fucking way I am facing the same adversity as a minority status sex worker in her 40's. Or, I could have just left off the age, let's leave it at "minority sex worker." It's an intersection of age, gender, sexual orientation, class, race, and to pretend that it's not is just ignorance, period. What does this really mean in terms of choice? What do I do with this knowledge and how can I still do good work within the community? Well, that's a conversation for another day, and one in which I look forward to having with others at the Desiree Alliance conference. My chat with this professor primed me for many NECESSARY conversations in the future. But, back to objectification. It's her belief that pornography, and the constant images of "sexy" women that serve as nothing more than jerk-off material, perpetuate a culture in which women's bodies are used and discarded. We agreed on the terms of objectification, but not on the implications. I am objectifying myself, there's no doubt about it. Do I feel good about this objectification, and am I making a choice to do it? Yes, and yes. It was a refreshing discussion, because unlike so many other feminists that I have talked to, her response was "and that's your choice, and it's okay. But, in regards to this issue, you're not a feminist." Would you believe that I actually felt liberated when she said this? I'm not a feminist, and that's okay. No judgment, no shaming, no chastising. I am making a choice, and that's okay. It also doesn't mean that I can't hold feminist ideals in other arenas, it doesn't need to be so black and white. Honestly, one of the most thought-provoking conversations that I have had in a long while.
Perhaps this objectification does have a negative impact on culture and the way in which women view themselves. Just as perhaps violent media and song lyrics have a negative impact, but again, what's the solution? We come full circle. It's not censorship; it's not pulling all porn off the internet; it's not telling sex workers to stop objectifying themselves; it's not telling Rhianna that she needs to stop expressing herself. Or that she needs to make a public apology, just to make US feel better about HER trauma.
I feel the need to end this article by saying that I wrote this much as I would write an entry in my journal. These are only my views, and they're expressed (perhaps not as eloquently as they could have been) after five days at a conference. I wanted to share some of my thoughts and insights, and that's it. Pick them apart and bitch at me all you want, but they're still only MY views, and I'm allowed to have them.. Thanks for reading.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
